Harper Broussard's daughter Georgina, was snatched fourteen years ago during a Mardi Gras parade. When she's found making cappuccinos behind the counter of a New Orleans coffee shop, Harper's ex-husband Remy assumes this is another false alarm. But the woman who kidnapped Georgina admits to her crime. Georgina, now known as Lilla, returns to her birth parents: a wary, confused teenager who has never known any mother except the loving woman who's now serving time. Harper's younger daughter, Josephine, has spent her life competing with the ghost of a perfect, missing sister. And though Remy has agreed to give their strained marriage another chance, he and Harper struggle to connect. Will Harper be able to redefine her idea of motherhood and family?