Widowed sisters Esther and Lizzie are the town innkeepers--and the town matchmakers. But when a new tenant moves into a guest cottage at their Peony Inn, the sisters are shocked to discover that maybe this time, one of them might finally find a match of her own. Retired dentist Dr. Benjamin Stoltzfus has signed a lease at the cottage--and Esther and Lizzie are in a surprising competition for the his affections. Benjamin's granddaughter, Mindy, escaping her big-city life, has moved to Amish country to be closer to her grandfather and to embrace the simpler life. But she's unprepared for Gabriel, an attractive young Amish man, who spends time at the inn helping out the widows.