When widowed schoolteacher Tobit Lapp is injured, he reluctantly agrees he needs Cora Koffman's help. Cora's still upset Tobit got the job at the Amish schoolhouse, but she agrees to teach his class till he's able. As they work together on lessons, a surprising friendship blossoms between them, but Tobit's heart is torn. He's falling for Cora--yet his secret could ruin everything...