Seventeen-year-old Becca Hart has not believed in true love for years and when her best friend makes fun of her for not having a boyfriend, Becca pretends that she has been secretly seeing someone. Brett Wells is the captain of the football team so he should have no problem finding someone to date, but he is more focused on his future than who to take to prom. He just happens to overhear Becca's lie and decides to step in and be her mystery guy. It's the perfect solution until they realize that acting as the perfect couple is not exactly easy.