Sutter Keely (Miles Teller), a high school kid with effortless charm and the self-proclaimed 'life of the party,' is having the perfect senior year - until he loses both his girlfriend and his part-time job. But when he meets Aimee, the 'nice girl' next door, an unlikely romance begins as Sutter and Aimee struggle to overcome their differences and help each other through the many challenges of growing up.