A sadistic killer appears to be targeting the perpetrators of a rape. When Michael McCabe is contacted by Rachel Thorne, who claims her husband, Josh, has gone missing while on a business trip, he and Savage are skeptical, but when she shows them a picture of her husband tied to a bed with a sign that says “Rapists Get What Rapists Deserve,” they’re compelled to act. During the investigation, they discover Josh’s connection to Hannah Reindel, who was raped by a group of athletes 12 years earlier when she was a college student and recently committed suicide by jumping off a bridge.